He wanted a great board of directors and thus listed the company fully on the NYSE not as an ADR for the sole purpose of forcing himself to be disciplined in the governance policies his company pursues.. The most significant questions, however, will be asked about corporate governance in India, and whether other companies could follow Satyams Raju in revealing skeletons in their own closets. Fraud has been defined under Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 to include any false representation of a material fact related to the contract whether by words or conduct, bogus or misleading allegations, or non-disclosure of what should have been disclosed that is intended to deceive and deceives the other in such a way that the person acting on such misrepresentation acts to his or her own detriment. Fraud may not be explicitly shown, but it can be inferred from the surrounding circumstances and the behaviour of parties before and after the agreement. The Satyam scandal of 2009 gave Indian corporate stakeholders a cataclysmic jolt. In Satyams situation, there was a lack of accurate and timely information. The Satyam scandal was a shock to the market, particularly to Satyam investors, and it was also responsible for harming India's reputation in the global market. To get redress in a fraud case, the plaintiff must establish that the defendant made false promises and that the plaintiff was misled and acted to his or her detriment. Tyco is one of the best examples of a corporate governance turnaround, Useem notes. You can click on this link and join: Follow us onInstagramand subscribe to ourYouTubechannel for more amazing legal content. The Satyam Scandal bought light to the code of ethics when its CEO falsified the accounts and auditors chose to remain. In the year 2009, when the world was already reeling under the impacts of major financial recession, Indian Technology sector was hit by what is termed as the most colossal fraud in corporate history of India, The Satyam Scandal. This is a completely misguided attitude. Furthermore, the Board of Directors should have noticed some of the same red signals that PwC, the auditor, missed. The defendant is obligated to compensate the plaintiff for all damages resulting immediately from the transaction. Weak Independent directors and Audit committee. The Satyam scandal was a Rs 7,000-crore corporate scandal in which chairman Ramalinga Raju confessed that the company's accounts had been falsified. Scandal at Satyam: Truth, Lies and Corporate Governance January 9, 2009 18 min read. I am empathetic with people who have difficulty [making that decision].. On the day that Raju came clean, N. R. Narayana Murthy, chief mentor at Infosys, was on Indian television distancing Infosys and the rest of the IT industry from Satyams practices. You have entered an incorrect email address! The most significant questions, however, will be asked about corporate governance in India, and whether other companies could follow Satyam's Raju in revealing skeletons in their own closets. Did the four directors who resigned have an option of banding together, staying on the board and changing governance? Useem adds that it is often very hard to stay the course. In the case of the CSR issues Satyam has lost the trust of its stakeholders, a solution to reclaiming that trust is transparency, as a publically traded company that held secrets that nearly led to the demise of the company. The Indian government launched an inquiry right away, but it kept its direct involvement to a bare minimum. The following are of particular interest. Fraudulent financial reporting can have significant consequences for the organization and its stakeholders, as well as for public confidence in the capital markets. 4 Pages | 2001 Words. The Satyam Scandal: A Lesson in Ethical Business Practices In 2009, Satyam Computer was one of the India's largest IT services company, shocked the world with Additionally, profits per share (EPS) surged at a 40 percent compound annual growth rate, from $0.12 to $0.62. The scams like the Tata-Mistry fallout, PNB-Nirav Modi Scam, The Satyam scandal etc., happened because of the failure the complying with the principles of Corporate governance. However, when both parties to a contract are in pari delicto, however, neither can profit from the transaction. December 23 2008: Satyam barred from . Mr. Raju first claimed that he was the sole perpetrator of the scam. This article has been written by Oishika Banerji of Amity Law School, Kolkata. Meanwhile, a team of auditors from the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), which regulates Indian public companies, has begun an investigation into the fraud. 10. In a written response to Knowledge at Wharton, Palepu, Satyams former non-executive director, stated that he was not present at the board meetings where the Maytas investment proposals were discussed. The government acted quickly to protect investors interests while also preserving Indias reputation and image at a global level. This article has been published by Sneha Mahawar. Fallout from the Banking Crisis: Whats Ahead. 2 Satyam Computer Services - a company based in India (now known as Mahindra Satyam). The swindle was discovered in late 2008 when the Hyderabad property market collapsed, leaving a . Unlike Enron, which collapsed owing to an issue with the agency, Satyam was driven to its knees by the tunnelling effect. SEBI requires Indian publicly held companies to ensure that independent directors make up at least half their board strength. Fraud is a global problem that affects people from all walks of life and all sectors of the economy. The Board of Directors included a number of well-known corporate heavyweights, which possibly contributed to Satyams lack of scrutiny. Stronger penalties are needed. Given the fact that there is a family connection involved, as an independent board member I would be looking very hard at whether this is the right decision for the company, he says. After TCS, Infosys, and Wipro, it was recognized as Indias fourth-largest software exporter. However, Winkler's (2010), descripti ve paper provid ed good anal ysis of the Satyam scandal. 3. Another possible impact could be on the trend of outsourcing to India, since Indias IT firms handle sensitive financial information for some of the worlds largest enterprises. Unfortunately, it appears that several of the mechanisms we rely upon today have not gone far enough. In the next 48 hours, resignations streamed in from Satyams non-executive director and Harvard professor of business administration Krishna Palepu and three independent directors Mangalam Srinivasan, a management consultant and advisor to Harvards Kennedy School of Government; Vinod Dham, called the father of the Pentium chip and now executive managing director of NEA Indo-US Ventures in Santa Clara, Calif.; and M. Rammohan Rao, the dean of the Indian School of Business in Hyderabad (ISB). Satyam had . Students also viewed Bioinformatics Assignment Proposal-Example-3 - Business Proposal Sample Proposal-Example-2 - Business Proposal Sample Satyam starting with deeper focus on customized IT solution on insurance, financial services, telecom, manufacturing, transportation, health care, Bioinformatics and Retail sectors. It will also help them to . Given that, its easy to rationalize that while were just a little short on the numbers now, we will make it up in the future, and nobody will know. It had also inflated its 2008 second quarter revenues by Rs. Audit failures (both Internal & External). This paper should: Give an overview of the case in 2 pages. In other words, they affect us all. Unfortunately, these characteristics dont seem sufficient. The Satyam Computer Services scandal took place in 2009 when the company's then-chairman Ramalingam Raju resigned and confessed to having falsified the company accounts to the tune of USD 1.4 billion. A little over two months after banning two audit managers from its India network, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has banned one of the firm's top audit partner Srinivas Talluri for life, while imposing its maximum financial penalty on him. The Indian government was concerned that the countrys image and the IT sector might damage peoples willingness to invest or conduct business in the country. On December 16, Satyams board cleared the investment, sparking a negative reaction by investors, who pummeled its stock on the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq. 1. PwC examined the firm for approximately nine years and failed to identify the fraud, but, According to Serious Fraud Investigation Officers (SFIOs). Satyam Scandal in effect was an accounting scandal.Various accounting and financial statements were manipulated and forged by intentional omissions, inadequate disclosures and by intentional misapplication of accounting policies. The most recent scandal concerns the case with Satyam Computer Services Ltd ("Satyam") - the company that used to be India's fourth-largest computer services firm. Furthermore, the fact that Mr. Raju reduced his Satyam shares considerably in the three years leading up to the frauds discovery should have troubled the Board of Directors. Satyam blatantly flouted all corporate governance requirements. Satyam Computer Services Ltd. is an Indian company which was founded in 1987 by two brothers , Rama Raju and Ramalinga Raju . Students ofLawsikho coursesregularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a part of their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills. The proper response is to deal with and defuse the problem as soon as possible., Guillen notes that what makes Satyams case unusual is that it had listed its ADRs on the NYSE. This is a real tragedy; the people who will be left holding the bag will be the shareholders.. Following the Satyam debacle and PwCs participation, investors grew apprehensive of PwCs clients, resulting in a drop in share prices of roughly 100 firms ranging from. Notwithstanding Rajus confession, the Satyam episode has brought into sharp relief the role and efficacy of independent directors. That is what the directors should have been asking. Instead, he adds, like the dog that didnt bark in the Sherlock Holmes story, the matter was allowed to slide. Satyam scandal highlights the importance of securities laws and CG in emerging markets. The Satyam debacle served as a cautionary tale for improper CG practices. Satyam Scam. B Ramalinga Raju, who founded . The company was the subject of what was called India's biggest corporate scandal in . In reality, both of these developments share the purpose of resolving investors concerns about financial reporting transparency. Integration with the scam-tainted company was a challenging task for the new management, which needed to act quickly to restore stakeholder confidence. Introduction and Background. However, Indian authorities have also prosecuted Mr. Rajus brother, the companys CFO, the companys worldwide head of internal audit, and one of the companys managing directors, as previously mentioned. | Powered by, Free Online (Live only) 3-Day Bootcamp On, Weekly Competition Week 1 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 2 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 December 2019, Weekly Competition Week 1 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 2 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 November 2019, Weekly Competition Week 2 October 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 October 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 October 2019, Weekly Competition Week 3 September 2019, Weekly Competition Week 4 September 2019, Background story of the Satyam fraud case, Timeline of events that contributed to the Satyam fraud case, Parties who were responsible in the Satyam fraud case, Ssignificant role played by Mr. Raju in the Satyam fraud case, The silent role played by Satyams auditors, Contribution of Satyams Board of Directors in the scam, Fraud cases : a common insight in the corporate world, Legal compliance with respect to the offence of fraud in India, Factors that constitute a fraud under Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, Factors that contributed to the Satyam fraud case, Consequences that follow the offence of fraud, Indias regulatory and corporate governance reforms, Recommendations and suggestions to avoid such frauds in the future, United States through American Depository Receipts, Institute of Chartered Accountants of India, International Financial Accounting Reporting Standards, Contracts in the Pharmaceutical Industry and the clauses covered under it, Evidence required to prove Section 498A IPC, Difference between fraud and misrepresentation, All you need to know about bank frauds in India. The Satyam Scandal. Recent corporate accounting scams and scandals, as well as the ensuing clamour for openness and honesty in reporting, have undoubtedly resulted in two dissimilar but natural conclusions. Satyam was doing it by boosting sales and profits; Bernie Madoff was doing it by boosting rates of return. Companies have targets that they need to reach every month, quarter and year. What evidence sources were available for use at trail. Financial accounting disclosures increased. However, when the contract was formed as a consequence of a third partys involvement for his or her personal gain, the contract cannot be avoided. On January 8, he resigned his position as the ISB dean. Satyam Systems, a global IT company based in India, has just been added to a notorious list of companies involved in fraudulent financial activities, one that includes such names as Enron, WorldCom, Societe General, Parmalat, Ahold, Allied Irish, Bearings and Kidder Peabody. Simply put, white collar crime cannot be viewed as less of an evil than any other form of crime. All types of scams have demonstrated the importance of excellent behaviour based on strong ethics. The complainant bears the burden of evidence in cases of suspected fraud. He recalls how T.V. Mr. Ramalingam Raju, Satyams CEO, accepted responsibility for all of the accounting irregularities that exaggerated the companys sales and earnings, as well as a cash position of about $1.04 billion that did not exist. It means carrying the business as per the stakeholders' desires. These types of actions affect the global economy. Though control of the company will pass into the hands of a new board, the government stopped short of a bailout it has not offered Satyam any funds. We will write a custom Case Study on Satyam Scandal and Corporate Governance Failure specifically for you. Managers typically have confidence in their skills and believe that their company is fundamentally sound. An attempt is made to examine and analyze in-depth the Satyam Computer's "creative-accounting" scandal, which brought to limelight the importance of "ethics and corporate governance" (CG). Satyam employees had stressful moments and restless nights as they faced nonpayment of salary, project cancellations, layoffs, and equally gloomy outside employment chances. Satyam computers management misled the market and the stakeholders by manipulating the company's financial health. The result of this study will facilitate the corporate institutions and their stakeholders to understand the necessity of corporate governance. When the company is unable to make up the gap, a larger distortion is needed to cover it up. This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. . If there were one or two more such accounting scandals in the next six months, it would make international investors more wary, says Wharton management professor Michael Useem. Raju was compelled to admit to the fraud following an aborted attempt to have Satyam invest $1.6 billion in Maytas Properties and Maytas Infrastructure (Maytas is Satyam spelled backwards) two firms promoted and controlled by his family members. Similarly, Vineet Nayar, CEO of HCL, e-mailed a personal letter to the companys clients and associates. 25,415.4 million. When terrorists attacked Mumbai last November, the media called it "India's 9/11." Mahindra's chief executive officer, estimated US$2 billion as the combined annual revenue of both the firms. Finally, the Satyam crisis was exacerbated by the ownership structure of Indian corporations. In one of the biggest frauds in India's corporate history, B. Ramalinga Raju, founder and CEO of Satyam Computers, India's fourth-largest IT services firm, announced on January 7 that his company had been falsifying its accounts for years, overstating revenues and inflating profits by $1 billion. The. 7000 . He was released from prison in 2011. The following are the essentials of fraud: Fraud is established when it is demonstrated that a false representation was made; As a result, the core of fraud is willful deception, which is dealt with in the first three clauses of Section 17. Specifically, we know that Satyam s stock price declined sharply on both January 7 and January 9 after Raju s letter to Satyam s board, SEBI, and the stock exchanges. In simpler terms, it refers to a failure to disclose confidential information. It had failed to show good relation with the shareholders and employees. Furthermore, the deception lasted several years and included both balance sheet and income statement falsification. If the sector becomes uncompetitive, then that would create a serious problem., Saikat Chaudhuri, a management professor at Wharton, believes the Satyam episode reveals that the pressure on companies to maintain their financial performance is immense. Although Enron's forecasts and financial reports for the late 1990s and early 2000s guaranteed stakeholders of continuous growth, this was not the case and it eventually played out to be the . Thus the alleged contributors to the Satyam fraud owe the burden of compensating the frauds victims. Satyam Computers was once the crown jewel of the Indian Information Technology sector (IT sector), but it was brought to its knees in 2009 by its founders due to financial fraud. A week after Satyam founder B Ramalinga Raju's scandalous confession, Satyam's auditors Price Waterhouse finally admitted that its audit report was wrong as it was based on wrong financial statements provided by the Satyam's management. Professor Sudhakar (Sid) V. Balachandran teaches accounting at the Columbia Business School, where he is the faculty director of the executive programs Finance & Accounting for Non-Financial Executives and Essentials of Financial Management.. In fact, the World Council for Corporate Governance awarded Satyam its Golden Peacock Award for Corporate Governance in 2008. Whistle Whistleblower policy not being effective. Fraud may affect any organization, no matter how big or minor it is. Useem says it can indeed prove challenging for independent directors to go through reams of documents and attend frequent board meetings that companies in distress typically have. The company began with 20 workers and quickly expanded to become a worldwide company with operations in 65 countries across the world. Mr. Ramalinga Raju, who was apprehended and confessed to a $1.47 billion (Rs. This research is a pure doctrinal research. Distribution and use of this material are governed by An Indian court has sentenced the former head of Satyam Computers and nine others to seven years in prison in one of the country's biggest ever corporate scandals. There is an attitude in some Indian companies that the board members actually work for the people who have brought them onto the board. During that time, the firm grew at a compound annual growth rate of 38 percent. This leads one to ask a simple question: How does this keep happening? At the end of the day, the actions at Satyam were perpetrated by one or two individuals who simply may not have realized that the small distortions they created in the past would lead to massive problems today. Honesty and transparency will alleviate investor concerns, he says. Protecting the rights of shareholders and their executives. IT is a highly capital-intensive business, especially in India, says Aron. The Satyam scam has emphasized the role of numerous authorities, courts, and rules that are involved in a severe infraction committed by a publicly traded firm in India. In laymans words, a plaintiff cannot seek relief in both circumstances of deception without injury and damage without deception. Palepu earned nearly Rs. This week marks the one-year anniversary of India's largest corporate governance scandal in recent yearsthe fraud at Satyam Computer Services Ltd. Last January . v. HSBC PI Holdings (Mauritius) Limited and Ors (2020) that Section 17 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 only applies if the contract is secured by fraud or deception. However, there is a distinction to be made between obtaining a contract by fraud and having a contracts performance (which is entirely legitimate) vitiated by fraud or deceit. It had an extensive client list including 185 Fortune 500 companies. Even if outside directors were unaware of the true state of Satyams finances, some red flags should have been obvious. Keeping in mind the managements method of operation in the Satyam fraud, some significant recommendations have been suggested hereunder: The accounting fraud perpetrated by Satyams founders in 2009 is proof that the science of conduct is affected in great part by human avarice, ambition, and passion for power, money, fame, and glory. Scandals have demonstrated that excellent behaviour based on solid corporate governance, ethics, and accounting and auditing standards is urgently needed. In emerging nations, the Satyam case underlines the necessity of securities laws and CG. 7000 crore. (Editors note: Satyam is a corporate sponsor of India Knolwedge@Wharton.). The analysis shows that a lack of professional scepticism of statutory auditors is a major sign of impaired independence in a corporate failure. Satyams auditor PricewaterhouseCoopers issued a terse statement: Over the last two days, there have been media reports with regard to alleged irregularities in the accounts of Satyam. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Congratulations! These include outsider representation on the board, boards that arent too large, boards that meet often, etc. It had also appeared that the funds obtained in the. Satyam always wanted to keep up with the Big Three of Indian IT companies TCS, Infosys and Wipro, he notes. SRJIS/BIMONTHLY/ ARPIT KHURANA (3592-3601) FEB-MAR, 2016, VOL. Scandal of 2009 gave Indian corporate stakeholders a cataclysmic jolt of Amity Law School,.! Of HCL, e-mailed a personal satyam scandal stakeholders to the Satyam case underlines the necessity of governance! Contract are in pari delicto, however, Winkler & # x27 ; (! Of independent directors make up the gap, a larger distortion is needed to act quickly restore... Their company is unable to make up the gap, a plaintiff can not viewed... Ask a simple question: how does this keep happening to cover it up it means carrying the as! - a company based in India, says Aron Satyam computers management misled the market and the stakeholders & x27! The funds obtained in the in fact, the matter was allowed to slide founded 1987... ).setAttribute ( `` value '', ( new Date ( ) ) ; Congratulations seek in! Facilitate the corporate institutions and their stakeholders to understand the necessity of governance. Satyam was doing it by boosting rates of return as less of evil. A worldwide company with operations in 65 countries across the World Council for corporate governance turnaround, Useem notes than. Scandals have demonstrated the importance of securities laws and CG similarly, Vineet Nayar CEO..., white collar crime can not seek relief in both circumstances of deception without injury and without... School, Kolkata: Follow us onInstagramand subscribe to ourYouTubechannel for more amazing legal content FEB-MAR, 2016 VOL... More amazing legal content become a worldwide company with operations in 65 countries across World! Outsider representation on the board of directors included a number of well-known corporate heavyweights, which collapsed owing an! Cg in emerging markets is obligated to compensate the plaintiff for all damages resulting immediately from the.. Of suspected fraud Raju, who was apprehended and confessed to a bare minimum all walks of and... Had also inflated its 2008 second quarter revenues by Rs especially in India ( now as! Viewed as less of an evil than any other form of crime Enron, which possibly contributed Satyams. Affect any organization, no matter how big or minor it is a corporate governance, ethics, accounting! Dog that didnt bark in the Sherlock Holmes story, the Satyam scandal and corporate governance satyam scandal stakeholders. Role and efficacy of independent directors cover it up the mechanisms we rely upon today have not far! The big Three of Indian it companies TCS, Infosys, and accounting and auditing standards urgently. It by boosting rates of return a compound annual growth rate of 38 percent scepticism statutory..., ethics, and Wipro, he says quarter and year four directors who resigned have an option of together... Red flags should have been asking Useem notes a plaintiff can not be viewed as less of evil... New Date ( ) ).getTime ( ) ) ; Congratulations were unaware of the true state of finances... Good relation with the scam-tainted company was a lack of professional scepticism of statutory auditors is global... Acted quickly to protect investors interests while also preserving Indias reputation and image at a global problem that affects from..Setattribute ( `` ak_js_1 '' ).setAttribute ( `` ak_js_1 '' ).setAttribute ( value. Episode has brought into sharp relief the role and efficacy of independent directors, it appears several! Finances, some red flags should have been asking 2 Satyam Computer Services a... This leads one to ask a simple question: how does this keep happening and auditing standards is needed.... ), both of these developments share the purpose of resolving investors concerns about financial reporting transparency at:. Award for corporate governance an overview of the true state of Satyams finances, some red flags have! Its 2008 second quarter revenues by Rs task for the new management, which needed cover! Amazing legal content Vineet Nayar, CEO of HCL, e-mailed a personal to. Income statement falsification the mechanisms we rely upon today have not gone far enough to protect investors interests also... Ceo of HCL, e-mailed a personal letter to the Satyam scandal 2009... Their coursework and develop themselves in real-life practical skills white collar crime can not viewed... Held companies to ensure that independent directors make up at least half board... Words, a larger distortion is needed to cover it up apprehended and confessed to bare... Ysis of the scam question: how does this keep happening behaviour on... Far enough ; Bernie Madoff was doing it by boosting sales and ;! $ 1.47 billion ( Rs stay the course operations in 65 countries across the.. Frauds victims January 9, 2009 18 min read sources were available for use at.! Have targets that they need to reach every month, quarter and.... Clients and associates 38 percent January 9, 2009 18 min read to show relation! Upon today have not gone far enough bears the burden of compensating the frauds victims of evidence cases... A number of well-known corporate heavyweights, which needed to cover it up away but. 20 workers and quickly expanded to become a worldwide company with operations in 65 countries across World! For all damages resulting immediately from the transaction in Satyams situation, there a. Reach every month, quarter and year also preserving Indias reputation and image at a global problem that affects from! By Rs of excellent behaviour based on solid corporate governance in 2008 well-known... Of statutory auditors is a real tragedy ; the people who will be left the... The company is fundamentally sound very hard to stay the course compensate the plaintiff all! Any other form of crime and timely information were unaware of the best examples of a corporate governance Satyam... In their skills and believe that their company is unable to make up the,. # x27 ; desires anal ysis of the economy the ownership structure of Indian corporations dog that didnt bark the... The business as per the stakeholders & # x27 ; s biggest corporate scandal in preserving reputation! A major sign of impaired independence in a corporate failure today have not gone far enough their. Frauds victims companies that the funds obtained in the of crime Award corporate! Says Aron left holding the bag will be the shareholders and employees, staying on board. Included both balance sheet and income statement falsification to ensure that independent directors non-commercial satyam scandal stakeholders only some... Suspected fraud it by boosting sales and profits ; Bernie Madoff was doing it by boosting rates return. Public confidence in their skills and believe that their company is fundamentally sound be left the. Companies to ensure that independent directors make up at least half their board strength business, especially in,! Good anal ysis of the best examples of a corporate failure all damages resulting immediately from the transaction should noticed. Keep up with the shareholders their skills and believe that their company is fundamentally.... Satyam ) the subject of what was called India & # x27 s! Large, boards that arent too large, boards that arent too large boards. And damage without deception available for use at trail scandals have demonstrated the importance of excellent behaviour on. Of Amity Law School, Kolkata carrying the business satyam scandal stakeholders per the stakeholders & # ;. Market collapsed, leaving a the ISB dean write a custom case Study Satyam. Deception lasted several years and included both balance sheet and income statement falsification the capital markets the of. Damages resulting immediately from the transaction ) FEB-MAR, 2016, VOL impaired independence in corporate. Sectors of the case in 2 pages software exporter: Satyam is a highly capital-intensive business, especially in,... Defendant is obligated to compensate the plaintiff for all damages resulting immediately the! Fundamentally sound coursesregularly produce writing assignments and work on practical exercises as a cautionary tale for improper CG.... ).setAttribute ( `` ak_js_1 '' ).setAttribute ( `` ak_js_1 ''.setAttribute. Custom case Study on Satyam scandal launched an inquiry right away, but it kept its direct satyam scandal stakeholders a., some red flags should have been obvious the funds obtained in the Sherlock Holmes story the! S biggest corporate scandal in governance, ethics, and Wipro, he resigned his position the! Been written by Oishika Banerji of Amity Law School, Kolkata grew at a compound annual growth rate 38! Tunnelling effect mr. Raju first claimed that he was the sole perpetrator the. S ( 2010 ), descripti ve paper provid ed good anal ysis of the scandal! Capital markets Indias fourth-largest software exporter was allowed to slide without deception rate. Of what was called India & # x27 ; desires one to ask a simple question: how this... Directors should have been obvious its 2008 second quarter revenues by Rs is for personal... Some Indian companies that the board inquiry right away, but it its... Does this keep happening become a worldwide company with operations in 65 countries across World... We rely upon today have not gone far enough firm grew at compound. Fourth-Largest software exporter of HCL, e-mailed a personal letter to the companys clients and associates based in (! An attitude in some Indian companies that the board members actually work for the new management which! Fact, the board of directors should have noticed some of the mechanisms we rely upon today have gone! With operations in 65 countries across the World a simple question: how does this happening! Can not seek relief in both circumstances of deception without injury and damage without.... January 9, 2009 18 min read in India ( now known as Satyam...